| THE PLAY | THE PERFORMANCE |
| Young Woodley | Roger Woodley · Westport Country Playhouse, Conn. 1946 · Beverly, MA 1946 · Six month Vaudeville Tour in America · Mexico City 1947 |
| MacBeth | Malcolm · Kingsbury Hall, University of Utah 1947 |
| The First Mrs. Fraser | Ninian Fraser · La Jolla Playhouse, CA 1948 |
| The Hasty Heart | Lachie · Lobero, Santa Barbara, CA 1948 · Tucson, AZ 1949 · New Orleans, LA 1950 · Laguna Beach, CA 1950 |
| O Mistress Mine | Michael Brown · Laguna Beach, CA 1950 · Sombrero Playhouse, Phoenix, AZ 1951 |
| The Youngest | Richard · Cape Playhouse, Dennis, MA July 2, 1951 · Playhouse-in-the-Park, Philadelphia, PA 1952 · Pocono Playhouse, Mountainhome, PA 1952 |
| Remains to Be Seen | Waldo Walton · Alcazar, San Francisco, CA 1952 |
| Misalliance | Bentley Summerhays · City Center, NYC Broadway Feb. 18 to Mar. 1, 1953 (16 performances) · Ethel Barrymore Theatre Mar. 6 to Aug. 1953 |
| Charley's Aunt | Lord Fancourt Babberley · Playhouse-in-the- Park, Philadelphia, PA 1953 |
| Debut | Dabney Featherstone · Municipal Theatre, St. Louis, MO 1953 |
| Escapade | Daventry · 48th Street Theatre, NYC Broadway Nov. 18-28, 1953 (13 performances) |
| Highlights of the Empire The Importance of Being Earnest (scene 4) |
Algernon · Empire Theatre, New York May 24, 1953 Closing of Empire Theatre |
| The Homeward Look | Edgar Cosgrove · Theatre DeLys, off-Broadway, June 3, 1954 |
| Aboard the Bandwagon | in revue · Bucks County Playhouse, New Hope, PA 1954 · Summer Playhouse, Andover, NJ 1954 summer stock |
| Bell, Book and Candle | Nicky Holroyd · Stamford, Conn. 1955 |
| The Doctor's Dilemma | Louis Dubedat · Phoenix Theatre, NYC off-Broadway Jan. 11 to Feb. 20, 1955 (48 performances) |
| The American Shakespeare Festival Julius Caesar The Tempest |
Octavius Caesar · Stratford, Conn. July, 12, 1955 Ariel · Stratford, Conn. Aug. 1 to Sept. 3, 1955 |
| No Time for Sergeants | Ben Whitledge · Alvin Theatre, NYC Broadway Oct. 20, 1955 to Oct. 1956 |
| The Diary of a Scoundrel | Yegor Gloumov · Phoenix Theatre, NYC off-Broadway Nov. 5-25, 1956 (24 performances) |
| Good as Gold | Benjamin Franklin · Belasco Theatre, NYC Broadway Mar. 7-9, 1957 (4 performances) |
| Compulsion | Artie Straus Broadway · Belasco Theatre, NYC Oct. 14, 1957 · Ambassador Theatre, NYC Oct. 24, 1957 to Feb. 22, 1958 (140 performances) |
| The Firstborn | Rameses · Hanna Playhouse, Cleveland, OH Mar. 31 to Apr. 5, 1958 · Royal Alexandra, Toronto, Ontario Apr. 7-12, 1958 · Colonial, Boston, MA Apr. 14-28, 1958 |
| Handful of Fire | Pepe · National Theatre, Washington DC Sept. 1-13, 1958 · Locust Theatre, Philadelphia, PA Sept. 15-17, 1958 · Martin Beck Theatre, NYC Broadway Oct. 1-4, 1958 (5 performances) |
| Look After Lulu | Marcel Blanchard · Shubert Theatre, New Haven, Conn. Feb. 16-21, 1959 · Henry Miller's Theatre, NYC Broadway Mar. 3 to Apr. 4, 1959 (39 performances) |
|
Time's Fool now known as The Fighting Cock |
Tarquin Edward Mendigales Tony Award-winning performance · Walnut Theatre, Philadelphia, PA Nov. 12-28, 1959 · ANTA Theatre Broadway Dec. 8, 1959 to Feb. 20, 1960 (87 performances) |
| Meet Me in St. Louis | Boy-Next-Door · Sacandaga, NY · Toronto, Ontario summer stock 1960 |
| Camelot | Mordred · O'Keefe Center, Toronto, Ontario Oct. 1-22, 1960 · Shubert Theatre, Boston, MA Oct. 25 to Nov. 1960 · Majestic Theatre, NYC Broadway Dec. 3, 1960 to Sept. 1961 |
| The Astrakhan Coat | Claud · Helen Hayes Theatre, NYC Broadway Jan. 12-28, 1967 (19 performances 5 previews) |
| A Shakespeare Cabaret | danced/sang with Jean Simmons · Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood, CA 1973 |
| Charley's Aunt | Lord Fancourt Babberley · Cirque Dinner Theatre, Seattle, WA Aug. 12, 1975 · Granny's Dinner Theatre, Dallas, TX Mar. 1976 · National tour May 10, 1976 to June 26, 1976 Ann Arbor, MI Wilmington, DE Montreal, Quebec Binghamton, NY Hamilton, Ontario Pittsburgh, PA Indianapolis, IN Louisville, KY Milwaukee, WI |
| Tubby the Tuba | reading with musical accompaniment · Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood, CA family concert 1975 |
| Otherwise Engaged | Simon Hench · Parker Playhouse, Fort Lauderdale, FL Jan. 9 to Feb. 4, 1978 |
| Harvey | Elwood P. Dowd · Fiesta Dinner Playhouse, San Antonio, TX 44 performances · New Orleans, LA 41 performances 1980 |
| Dial "M" for Murder | Inspector Hubbard · National tour Sept. 26, 1995 to Mar. 10, 1996 (150 performances) Detroit, MI Norfolk, VA Baltimore, MD Milwaukee, WI New Haven, CT Wilmington, DE Denver, CO Minneapolis, MN Green Bay, WI Cleveland, OH Philadelphia, PA Chicago, IL |
| A Christmas Carol | Scrooge
(alternating with Hal Linden) · The Theater at Madison Square Garden New York, NY Broadway November 18, 1997 to January 4, 1998 |